AXING OF MINISTER DION GEORGE – THE DEMOCRATIC ALLIANCE SHOWS ITS TRUE COLOURS

EMS FOUNDATION: PUBLIC STATEMENT 

18th November 2025

“Environmental protection and the rule of law must walk hand in hand, justice for the people and justice for the planet. Our country is rich in biodiversity, but that richness has made us a target.  Along our coasts, abalone poaching has become a global criminal enterprise. It strips our oceans bare and destroys the livelihoods of coastal communities.  In our parks, rhino horn and ivory trafficking continues to fuel violence and corruption.  Across our veld, captive-bred lions are raised for commercial hunting, reducing living creatures to commodities.  These are not legacies worth defending.  They are systems that must end.” 

These are the words of Dr Dion George, the former Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and  Environment, representing South Africa at the Rio Declaration on Crimes that Affect the Environment which was endorsedby eighteen governments, international environmental and civil society organisations  in Brazil on the 4thNovember 2025. 

When President Cyril Ramaphosa fired Dr Dion George as Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment, the official explanation was carefully scripted: “under-performance.” But the timing, the political choreography and the beneficiaries tell a far more revealing story — one that exposes the growing influence of wildlife-breeding and trophy-hunting lobbies inside government. George’s removal was not simply a cabinet reshuffle. It was a political execution. And South Africa’s wild life will pay the price.

When Dr Dion George took over from Barbara Creecy, he did not retreat from her bold and much needed environmental reforms; he deepened them. He embraced the High-Level Panel recommendations, which called for the end of captive lion breeding, the phasing out of intensive rhino farming, and a shift toward ethical, ecologically sound conservation. He: 

  • Moved to shut down the captive-lion industry, pushing forward with the voluntary exit programme. 
  • Set the lion-bone export quota at zero for 2025, effectively ending commercial trade in lion skeletons.  
  • Confirmed South Africa would not back any attempt to reopen international trade in rhino horn or ivory. 
  • Refused to issue trophy-hunting quotas for elephant, black rhino and leopard while a court case challenged the quota process. 
  • Defended animal-wellbeing provisions in NEMBA. 
  • Appealed the Kimberley High Court ruling that opened the door for exporting rhino horn from privately owned breeding facilities.

And that made Minister George dangerous — not to the public, not to conservation, but to powerful private interests who have long treated wildlife as inventory.

  • For years, South Africa’s predator-breeding, “game” ranching and trophy hunting sectors have worked to influence wildlife policy. Their goal is simple: derail reforms that restrict commercial exploitation. WRSA, SAPA, and SUCo-SA all had open conflicts with the DFFE under Ministers George and Creecy. They fought: 
  • the shutdown of the lion-bone industry; 
  • the phasing out of intensive rhino farming;
  • animal-wellbeing clauses they claim threaten “sustainable use,”; 
  • court rulings blocking lion-bone exports; and 
  • suspended trophy-hunting quotas.

When the Democratic Alliance became part of the interim government, its leader John Steenhuisen — previously Chief Whip, then Agriculture Minister — walked straight into the arms of the wildlife-breeding sector. Steenhuisen appeared visibly out of his depth in a portfolio dominated by complex legal and scientific issues. Observers say he relied heavily on DA figure Willie Aucamp, who enjoys significant rapport with wildlife ranchers and breeders. By early 2025, Steenhuisen was openly championing the industry:

  • At HuntEx in February, standing beside WRSA CEO Richard York, he declared: “Hunting is conservation.” 
  • By June, Aucamp was frequently seen with high-value game breeders like Colin Engelbrecht, who run predator-breeding facilities. 
  • By September, the DA’s courting of the sector was open and unapologetic. What began as proximity became alignment. What became alignment soon looked like capture.

Minister George’s sacking raises urgent questions:

  • Will Aucamp withdraw the state’s appeal in the rhino-horn case?
  • Will the lion-bone export quota be restored?
  • Will the captive lion industry gain new life?
  • Will trophy-hunting quotas be rushed through?
  • Will animal-wellbeing protections be gutted?

The EMS Foundation also notes the various likely disinformation campaigns designed to lay a clear path for Willie Aucamp and the sector he represents, by attempting to bring Dr Dion George’s integrity into disrepute using targeted tactics to manipulate public opinion, erode trust and create a negative narrative. This method to manipulate information was used during the Apartheid regime to discredit opponents and justify its racially oppressive policies. 

At the same time, we are also paying close attention to the pro trophy hunting rhetoric which pushes a flawed narrative that that hunting is a big money spinner.  The EMS Foundation undertook an independent technical review of these figures which highlights several methodological weaknesses that bring the hunters narrative into question. 

With the sanction of President Ramaphosa, the Democratic Alliance has not only shown its anti-environment true colours, but it has created a perfect storm of an ideologically compromised new Minister within a Department that has a long history of one-sided engagement with extractive industries, a largely untransformed mindset which views wild life as commodities, and some individuals in the department that are likely either motivated by money or stuck in apartheid legacy thinking. This is what both former Ministers, Creecy and George, were up against. It is therefore hugely ironic, given our history of State Capture and the fact that we are living in the Sixth Extinction where wild animals are facing growing extirpation, that both the ANC and the DA appear to be pushing this dangerous agenda. 

As a consequence, South Africa is facing massive reputational damage. The battle for South Africa’s wild life, its lions, rhinos and elephants has entered a new, volatile phase. Dion George may have fallen — but the fight for the soul of South African conservation is only beginning. We are at a crossroads, but be warned: civil society will not take this lying down. 

DOWNLOAD Background information and full media statement: