ELEPHANT CAPTIVITY HAS NO PLACE IN A DEMOCRATIC SOUTH AFRICA

Media Statement

The EMS Foundation has described the recent Gauteng High Court hearing concerning the continued captivity of Lammie, Mopane and Ramadiba at the Johannesburg Zoo as a defining moment for animal justice, constitutional values and the future moral direction of South Africa.

At the heart of the case lies a profound ethical and constitutional question: can a democratic society founded on dignity, compassion, equality and justice continue to justify the confinement of highly intelligent, emotionally complex and socially sophisticated beings for public display and entertainment?

Over three days, the Gauteng High Court in Pretoria has heard extensive legal, scientific and welfare arguments concerning the lives and wellbeing of the three elephants currently confined at the Johannesburg Zoo. The application was brought by Animal Law Reform South Africa, the EMS Foundation and Chief Stephen Fritz, Senior Chief of the South Peninsula Khoi Council.

The EMS Foundation argues that elephant captivity is fundamentally incompatible with both modern scientific understanding and the values South Africa claims to uphold as a constitutional democracy.

Elephants are not objects, exhibits or entertainment assets. They are autonomous, sentient beings with deep family bonds, advanced cognition, emotional intelligence, grief responses, social learning systems and extensive spatial and ecological needs. Scientific evidence before the Court highlighted that no urban zoo environment can adequately meet these needs. Captivity deprives elephants of agency, natural social structures, movement, stimulation and meaningful choice. 

Download Full Media Statement:

Media Enquiries: Megan Carr Towards Freedom Programme megan@emsfoundation.org.za